It's too fucking warm. Usually when I think November fishing, I'm expecting to be bundled up, freezing my ass off on a salmon stream or an inlet jetty or my beloved Delaware hoping to tickle up a few walleyes. But this year, we had temperatures up into the mid-70's when my more festive friends are starting to play Christmas music, much to my dismay. However, October had semi-normal October weather, so the water temps haven't been affected too much.
On Salmon Camp Eve, Victor and I decided to hit a local inlet jetty for the feisty little Jersey tarpon known as the hickory shad. Hickories are an underrated light tackle delight; if they're in the mood, they hit any small lure or fly and will jump like their cousin the Silver King. We also picked up some green crabs, hoping to poke around for some big fall tautogs.
We pulled up in the afternoon, right before high tide. There was no sign of bait around, so I began cutting crabs and dropping them down tog holes with rigs, starting all too familiar cycle of crunch, swing, and miss. All of a sudden, my crab gets walloped on the way down. I swing, my rod doubles over, and I feel the sickening scrape of mono leader dragging over rocks. My rod pops back up and my line goes slack. Tog 1, Alan 0. A few minutes later, I lost another big tog on the same rock. I've heard blackfish gurus say that big tog stick to rocks in pairs. After losing both members of a pair, I'm a believer.
Soon after, the man next to me lands a hickory. I start casting a small pink albie metal, and get picked up. A flash of silver, a jump, and this shad shakes the hook. An oldhead next to me yells a word of advice, but I can't hear it over the wind and waves. I learned over, cupped my hand around my ear, and yelled back.
"I'm sorry?"
"Sorry?" he yelled back. "What you saying sorry for? You're too young to be sorry. Wait until you're old like me, then you're allowed to be sorry. I was telling you that the shad hit sabiki rigs. Go out there and catch 'em." Two different pieces of advice in one exchange, one fishing, one life. It's incredible how much advice concerning the two intertwine out on the water, even in a place like dirty Jersey where everyone's supposed to be an asshole.
I continue casting my metal out of sheer laziness, but let it sink to the bottom and jig it, like how someone would fish a sabiki. I get smacked and land my first hickory shad of the year. Victor puts on a sabiki and starts hammering fish on a fast retrieve.
The shad were being picky. They wanted a bait fished much closer to the bottom than what I'm usually using for them. I got many hits, but few hook ups and most of the fish I hooked managed to spit the lure. Frustrated, I put on a tog jig and crab and sent it to the bottom. I feel a set of crunches, and swing as hard as I can. The medium bass rod I'm using bends into a hula hoop and I have to cup my spool to give the fish as little room as possible to run into the cover. It breaks the surface, and it's one of my biggest land based togs, missing a chunk out of the top of it's head, most likely from an osprey encounter when it was young. I harvested that fish for the dinner table.

While I was fooling around with tog, Victor continued to put a smackdown on the hickory shad using both sabikis and a variety of small soft plastics. We were a little short of a limit, and lost just about as many fish as we hooked (many more in my case). The acrobatic displays of aerial feats that these silvery little fish can produce more than made up for it.
I've never done much land based tog fishing this late in the year. However, I've heard that you get shots at much bigger fish, and after this trip, I'm a believer in both going later and learning the jig. I believe it's light tackle and tog jigs that finally gave these fish the popularity that they deserve, and it makes me happy to see more and more people out every year having fun trying to learn the difference between a scratch and a thump. As for the shad? Hook one in heavy current on light tackle and it'll speak for itself. Cheers, fishy people.