"I lived Narcotic hours in which like the Taoist Chuang-tse I worried about butterflies and who was dreaming what" - Ed Abbey
An Appalachian river at nighttime is a near surreal experience. The low whine of insects pose riddles and koans in your ears and every single splash in the dark is warped and twisted by your mind to be the twisting of a 30 inch brown trout that just sipped off the surface a mouse, frog, or baby bird. Imagination runs wild at night, morphing sounds and little pockets of sight into feelings that tickle up the spine and pound in the back of the throat.
I've been getting into the night-fishing game as of late. Our rivers in Central Pennsylvania right now are running low and clear due to the lack of rain, leaving brown trout feeling over-exposed to the outside world at day. However, under the cover of night when ospreys and eagles are all tucked away, they feel right at home and in the mood to kill stuff. When you're standing in the complete darkness of a riverbank with only the hum of no-see-ums and the rippling riffles, launching a mouse fly on a 6wt as close to the opposite bank as possible, slowly stripping it across the surface, and then come tight from a river brown trying its darn hardest to drown your fly, it's a magical thing. Makes you want to stand and holler to the owls and the Appalachian mountain stars above.
Before this night, I spent a bit of time looking for dry fly opportunities on Spruce Creek. October Caddis are the main hatches here in Pennsylvania this time of year, but on this day, they were showing in very few numbers. A few fish were rising here and there, and I managed to pick off a few small wild browns and rainbows, mostly blind casting. Hatches are a fickle thing out East, I try not to chase them. The highlight of Spruce Creek ended up being an easily 22 inch brown I spotted lazily hovering around the deepest pool of the creek, utterly uninterested in even moving any fly presented to him.
In the valley bottom, the black walnuts have just lost their leaves while the sugar maples and basswoods are starting to turn and the sassafras lights up the hills like a twisting, winding inferno. I cut a twig of it, chew out the oils, twist it around my fingers. Sassafras has some incredible properties. The oils quicken the heart-rate and sweat glands, giving it a medicinal property. Some daring folks have even successfully synthesized MDMA with the stuff.
I made the decision to move to a slightly larger river with much more flat water before dark. Still chewing my sassafras twig, I sat upon the riverbank and watched. Some caddis were hatching, a few fish were rising here and there but nothing super violent, no carnage or blitzes of trout and insect. Soon, the sun sank down below the mountains and the stars slowly turned on above. I rigged up a mouse fly and slowly walked into the water.
I made a cast across current, a short upstream mend, and squinted in the dusk of the river to the silhouette of my fly slowly swinging across the current. On my third cast, my eyes barely made out the splash of a trout swiping behind my fly. On the fourth, I hooked him.
I've had a lot of moments in my seven years of trying to fool ichthyological life that a simply "holy shit that actually worked" can summarize. Most recently were my first pike and bowfin, but my first snakehead, first fish on topwater, first trout on the fly all come to mind. My first brown trout on a mouse fly at night was up there.
Soon, it grew fully dark, with a large bright gibbous moon above my head and clouds of insects that swarmed by face every time I turned on the light to land a fish or undo a tangle. Night fishing's all about feel, something I learned in the walleye scene back home, and I soon came tight to another fish just upstream, one that put the line on the reel and made a huge run downstream. I flipped my light on, got a face full of insects, but was rewarded with my biggest brown trout on the fly so far.
Soon after the release of that trout and the settling of the waning gibbous moon above the river, I slowly but surely waded up to a more open section of river, a pool too slow for me to effectively nymph during the day. At night, the floodgates went wide open. Almost every cast I had a swipe, follow, boil right behind the fly. I ended up landing 8 more fish in that stretch, including a rock bass that took me by surprise.
My last fish of the night ended up being another 16 inch brown, one that had barely sipped the mouse off the surface, so subtly that I didn't see the take and hooked the fish as I began my retrieve.
At this point of the night, it was getting late and my mind was playing more tricks on me than I would have liked, meaning the time for me to pack it up was nigh. I drove for a while along the backroads of Central Pennsylvania, nothing but my own thoughts and music belting along to each other in the cool night air. Eventually, I stopped in a section of Rothrock State Forest, pitched a tent, and slept there, under a blanket of stars that shone as bright as the jewels of the East without the hustling neon of city lights to overtake them.